Pan's Labyrinth: From Aschenputtel to Ofelia

The Connections

In Guillermo del Toro's film, Pan's Labyrinth, the journey of a young girl, Ofelia, during post civil war times. After her father's death, her mother remarries Captain Vidal, a vicious man guided by no moral compass, only a loyalty to Franco's lead and a desire to preserve his family name through a son. Life with the Captain is unbearable. Ofelia turns to a fairy tale world as a way for escape. In this world, there are parallels to the real world as well as the Grimm Brothers' Aschenputtel. As I summarized that tale in the previous blog, I won't be doing that here- rather I will be focusing on it's connection to Pan's Labyrinth. 

The first comparison is in the loss of the mother in both tales. In Aschenputtel,  the father is still alive, but does not do anything to protect or care for Aschenputtel. In this way both protagonists are left in the care of a step parent that has no regard for their well being. 

In both tales, there is also a guiding character that assists our protagonist. In Aschenputtel, the tree that grew from her tears on her mother's grave has the role we would normally associate with the fairygodmother, as it is the aids Aschenputtel by granting her wishes, having the birds assist her with her tasks and work as guides throughout the tale. In del Toro's tale, the faun is Ofelia's guide providing assistance with her tasks and guiding her toward her path to the underworld.

A large area of comparison in both of these tales is the use of tasks. In both tales, the protagonists need the assistance of others in order to complete the tasks. Aschenputtel receives the help of birds, while Ofelia has fairies that the faun has sent to help her. Aschenputtel needs to sort lentil beans from the ash ridden floor. Ofelia must obtain a key and then a dagger, both in dangerous circumstances.

The rule of three is a staple of many fairy tales, is a strong characteristic of these tales as well. In the film, Ofelia must complete three tasks. One of which she feeds a large toad three stones in order to obtain a key, and in the second task she must decide which of three doors has the dagger she must acquire from a monster's layer. All of these tasks are leading to the reuniting of the trinity that is the royalty of the underworld (The King, Queen, and Princess Mona aka Ofelia). In Aschenputtel, the feast lasts three days, Aschenputtel wears three different gowns, and after her two step sisters tried on the golden slipper (third times the charm), the prince finds his partner. While the rule of threes isn't an Aschenputtel specific trait, both fairy tales utilize this.     

The last similarity to direct to is in the theme of eyes. In the original version of Aschenputtel, the step sisters have their eyes gouged out by birds as punishment for their wickedness. In Pan's Labyrinth, there is a creature that's eyes are initially seen sitting on a plate in front of it. This shows the use of "evil being blind" in both stories.

The role of the fairy tales

In Pan’s Labyrinth, the fairy tale idea is a powerful tool. Not only did it bring in a common story that has been told by many cultures in different ways. Fairy tales provide a beautiful and artistic way of illustrating life lessons, and about the progression from childhood into adulthood. In this film, the fairy tale world works as an escape from reality for the character of Ofelia. And although it is an escape, the fairy tale world mirrors the real world that Ofelia is struggling with. This tale shows the harshness of this time period on childhood innocence. The character of Mercedes mirrors Ofelia and her journey through the fairy tale realm (the task of retrieving the key for the storage shed, the knife she kept on her and used against the captain).This provided an additional message, that in the real world innocence doesn’t prevail. Those more hardened by reality survive. By the use of fairy tale, we can compare what is needed for survival, and see the value of purity of spirit. 

Pan's Labyrinth and the Grimms' Cinderella (Aschenputtel)

In the Brothers Grimm's version of Cinderella (called Aschenputtel) there is a similarity in the use of tasks as a way to obtaining an end result- ascending to a thrown in one case, attending a ball in another. 
In the tale of Aschenputtel, Aschenputtel's mother dies, leaving her with her father, a stepmother, and two step sisters. Aschenputtel grows up serving the family, not being cared and supported for by her father. When the day comes that the King is holding a three day celebration to find a wife for his son, the Prince, Aschenputtel wants to attend with the rest of the kingdom. Her step mother gives her impossible tasks to complete in order to go, which Aschenputtel completes with the help of birds.

     

When still told she cannot go, she wished under a tree that she had grown with her tears on her mother's grave, and a bird threw down a gown for her so she could attend. Aschenputtel attended all three days of the feast. On the final day she lost one of her gold slippers at the ball, which the prince then used to find her. 
      
In this version, the step sisters cut of parts of their feet in order to fit into the slipper. Once the prince finds and marries Aschenputtel, the birds that helped Aschenputtel along the way gouge out the eyes of the step sisters, blinding them.

Reflections on Water

    The film Water depicts the societal injustice that the widows of India are subjected to. With the death of a husband, widows are forced into a life of waiting to be reunited with their lost husbands. All the while, the widows are degraded as lesser members of society and even forced into prostitution. In this film, the lives of widows in Varanasi, India are depicted; showing their struggles, suffering, and humanity. An important element of this film is the connection of cultural mythology- the Hindu story of Radha and Krishna. The allusion of this tale is weaved into the story telling of the widows. 
    Widow Kalyani has an unexpected run in with Narayan, a young man who has his eyes opened to the plight of the widows that Gandhi is supporting because of this meeting. The two form a loving bond that is tragically cut short with the suicide of Kalyani, when she couldn't live with the her time in prostitution any longer. 
   The story of Kalyani and Narayan mirrors the story of Radha and Krishna. In the myth, Krishna is a great lover, holding Radha in the highest of affections. However, due to circumstance the two never end up married; Radha spends a lifetime waiting for Kirshna. In this way, Kalyani and Narayan's love mirrors this tragic and powerful story. Narayan will have to wait a lifetime to be reunited with Kalyani. The film gives clues to this with signs such as Narayan's appearances with a flute, something Krishna is often depicted with. Additionally, Narayan compares Kalyani to the beautiful peacock feather, another symbol of Krishna. 

    When looking at the use of cultural mythology in this film, Water uses the myth of Krishna and Radha as a tool to guide through a painful story reflecting of the challenges faced by widows. In this way in incorporates a story of love into a story that may otherwise be too painful to watch as well as reconnecting with the Hindu beliefs that are integral to the values behind widows and marriage in India. After considering the story of Krishna and Radha and it's representation of true love, how far should a culture take that principal? Where do we draw the line between religious values and our own free choice?

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       

Up, Up, and Away: the Music of Up

There are films that always seem to hit the right note when it came to the decisions on the use of music. A beautiful example of this would be in Pixar's UP. This film effectively used music to enhance the emotions of the scenes and in the case below, showed that dialogue isn't always needed to tell a powerful story. 

Tsotsi: Use of sound and music

In the film "Tsotsi", directed by Gavin Wood, music and sound provide  strong support for the atmosphere of the setting. The film takes place in South Africa, showing the character of Tsotsi, a young punk now struggling the the internal turmoil from the harm he's caused others. The soundtrack supports the setting of the urban, that Tsotsi comes from. The fast pace matches the quick moving lifestyle of crime that to this point, Tsotsi has embraced. 

Along with the soundtrack, the additional scores used in the film aided to setting the tone of the scenes. In the example below, the sounds of the train combined with the subtle sounds added in creates  an ominous tone that is mixed with a sense of urgency. This allows for the viewer to better place themselves in the scene that Wood is showing us, and to feel the horror of such a sudden act.